fbpx
  • HOME
    HOME
  • OUR WORK
    OUR WORK
  • OUR BLOG
    OUR BLOG
  • SHOPPER MAGAZINE
    SHOPPER MAGAZINE
    • VOLUME 6
      VOLUME 6
    • VOLUME 7
      VOLUME 7
    • VOLUME 8
      VOLUME 8
    • VOLUME 9
      VOLUME 9
    • VOLUME 10
      VOLUME 10
  • NEWSLETTERS
    NEWSLETTERS
  • SHOP WITH ME™
    SHOP WITH ME™
  • CONTACT US
    CONTACT US
  • SOCIAL FEEDS
    SOCIAL FEEDS
  • SOCIAL FEEDS
    SOCIAL FEEDS
CONTACT INFORMATION
Level 1, Tasman Building
16-22 Anzac Ave
09 300 4666
LATEST TWEETS
avatar-twitter
goodenergi
Follow On Twitter
Whole Foods founder John Mackey on having Jeff Bezos as a boss https://t.co/VHqKnIGFDs
13 days ago - goodenergi
2020 Was a Watershed Year for Retail Bankruptcies https://t.co/2Z4Po8PeoP
16 days ago - goodenergi
That's a wrap! As for many of us, 2020 has been a wild ride for Energi. While reflecting over the year that's been,… https://t.co/IHrp5mERwf
27 days ago - goodenergi
Energi December 2020 It's A Wrap - https://t.co/V3JF0SOkmx
30 days ago - goodenergi
INSTAGRAM FEED
  • Put your feet up this weekend with a copy of @unomagnz’s latest issue, featuring these two incredible @sheeo_world Activators who are doing their part to drive global change and uplift other women in the industry - and we’re loving it!

Link to the full article in our bio. 👆🏻
  • Once again, here at Energi it’s business as usual but remotely. Stay safe everyone.
  • Calling our fellow bookworms, today is for you! 📚

From your favourite sun-lounger spot, or perhaps tucked away in bed, there is no better way to celebrate #BookLoversDay than by kicking back with your favourite read. 

Check out our latest blog post to discover a few of our most-loved classics. Link in our bio!
  • Happy #InternationalBeerDay! 🍺

In honour of this fun global event, we’re very excited to share our most recent brew, Energi Rapsody!

What technically is a ‘Rhapsody’ you ask? It's a piece of music written without a formal structure, expressing powerful feelings and emotional excitement. In that note, our limited edition beersie is rich with highly contrasted tasting notes and colour!

This fresh brew is a Bohemian Pilsner with black pepper hops and spicy herbal undertones, that will take you on a journey.

Rhapsody comes along with a curated playlist of Rhapsodies to give you the full experience. 

Check out the playlist link in our bio!
logo-mobile-energi
  • HOME
    HOME
  • OUR WORK
    OUR WORK
  • OUR BLOG
    OUR BLOG
  • SHOPPER MAGAZINE
    SHOPPER MAGAZINE
    • VOLUME 6
      VOLUME 6
    • VOLUME 7
      VOLUME 7
    • VOLUME 8
      VOLUME 8
    • VOLUME 9
      VOLUME 9
    • VOLUME 10
      VOLUME 10
  • NEWSLETTERS
    NEWSLETTERS
  • SHOP WITH ME™
    SHOP WITH ME™
  • CONTACT US
    CONTACT US
  • SOCIAL FEEDS
    SOCIAL FEEDS
  • SOCIAL FEEDS
    SOCIAL FEEDS
logo-energi
logo-mobile-energi
To Blog
Cans

Unsightly Packaging

March 16, 2018
-
FMCG Articles, Shopper Behaviour, Shopper Experiences

I’m hopeless. As a foodie and a strategic planner for a shopper marketing agency a trip to the supermarket is never quick and always full of delight. I’m one of those people that gets lost in the aisles.

I double-back. I triple-back. I rarely buy on price, although sometimes I do when I feel the need for a bargain. I love trying new things. I’m a sucker for tasty samples. And I am a seasoned professional at watching how shoppers behave.

The beauty of supermarkets is that they are so full of diverse experiences, from bountiful fruit to bready aromas, to exotic spices, to the comforting softness of squidgy toilet tissue.

One of my favourite places is the cooking oil aisle. Like many sections, it has blossomed of late with new product development. It has rapidly evolved from a few staples to a fabulous array of Masterchef delights, flavoured infusions, and layers of value.

A lot of cooking oil brands have adopted wine cues such as provenance, single sources, craft extraction processes, evocative Latin imagery and seductive tasting notes. For the pleasure of the chef at home, it has drawn more from the deli than the dairy.

For the shopper, the cooking oil shelf offers a lot, and it also asks a lot. It engages and demands that you look before you buy. It wants you to spend a few moments to think about your food and the flavours you consume. Its path to purchase arrives at a destination that promises deliciousness.

But not the other day.

Standing in front of the cooking oil aisle I looked and looked, but my ‘go-to’ olive oil, my culinary friend of several years, was missing. Disheartened, I began searching for a replacement; of which there were many that met my brief.

Then, just before I was about to substitute, I found it. My old favourite, but in totally new packaging design. It had lost its shape. Its familiar and confident identity had become something strange and flimsy looking. They had changed its choice architecture and removed its helpful matching of variants to food.

The effect was that I had nearly lost my favourite brand in plain sight.

A couple of years ago I experienced another such example. A prominent food manufacturer with a category captain brand of several decades was ringing the alarm bells.

They had been suffering a long slow decline in sales, being chipped away at by new high-value products and undercut by price fighters. Meanwhile, they had under-invested in their cash cow for several years.

In order to turn things around, they spent heavily on new packaging design and advertising to make their brand more attractive. Unfortunately, these major changes were not tested in research. Instead of creating a lift, the brand fell off the sales cliff.

My brief was to help them solve the problem and set them back on track. The first conclusion was that the reason for the long slow decline and the reason for the sharp plummet were different. The long slow decline was the result of under-investment in an active, innovating category. Their strong brand had slipped behind in terms of product innovation and brand salience. It needed re-invigorating not re-inventing.

The reason for the sharp plummet in sales was that the packaging solution created a radical change that – like my olive oil – made the brand invisible on shelf to its loyal buyers. With an effective absence on shelf, shoppers simply substituted with other comparable brands in droves. In my in-store research, I stood in front of the shelf alongside shoppers who literally could not see their preferred brand sitting right in front of them. To rub salt in the wound it emerged that the expensive new packaging design turned out to be a close copy of a similar product in a foreign market.

While there are certainly times when a major makeover is required for a brand, there is a real risk of confusing and losing existing customers with radical change. An incremental approach is often a smarter way to go. The Apple logo story is a perfect example. The original logo was completely hideous and lived a mercifully short life. At that point, it needed a revolution. But once they adopted the bitten apple symbol, a path of managed continuity has kept the market in step with the brand’s evolution over the past 40 years.

The moral of the story is that in trying to give shoppers something new with your brand development, be careful with what you take away.

Tags
FMCG ArticlesLew Bentley
PREVIOUS POST
Rise of the DIFM christmas
NEXT POST
Creating the ultimate scroll-stopper
Newsletters
  • Energi November 2019 Newsletter
  • Energi October 2019 Newsletter
  • Energi September 2019 Newsletter

Related News

Other posts that you should not miss
FacebookChange

Facebook makes more… C-C-C-Changes

April 30, 2018

Q&A with Mel Lee – Strategic Director @ Backchat Media Facebook threw us all a curveball at the beginning of this …

Read More →
Culture, Shopper Experiences, Shopper Technology, Shopper Vol 6
4 MIN READ
ShoppingMall1

Retail apocalypse or rebirth?

April 18, 2019

Retail giants worldwide have been hitting hard times, with the closing of stores and loss of shopper interest, victims to the …

Read More →
Shopper Behaviour, Shopper Experiences, Shopper Vol 9, Shopping Trends
3 MIN READ
ScanAI

Cashier-less payments

December 14, 2018

Today’s customer is channel-agnostic, switching effortlessly between online and bricks-and-mortar buying and employing a blend of shopping techniques: patronizing physical stores …

Read More →
Shopper Behaviour, Shopper Experiences, Shopper Technology, Shopper Vol 8, Shopping Trends
7 MIN READ
LATEST POSTS
  • November 2, 2020
    Digital Day Out 2020 Takeaways
  • August 8, 2020
    Our Top 8 Must Reads for #BookLoversDay!
  • April 21, 2020
    The world on leadership in a time of crisis
  • April 21, 2020
    Marketing hits and misses in the time of a pandemic
GET CONNECTED

Stay up to date with the latest news by Energi, about Energi as well as insights from the world of shopper marketing.

  • Put your feet up this weekend with a copy of @unomagnz’s latest issue, featuring these two incredible @sheeo_world Activators who are doing their part to drive global change and uplift other women in the industry - and we’re loving it!

Link to the full article in our bio. 👆🏻
  • Once again, here at Energi it’s business as usual but remotely. Stay safe everyone.
  • Calling our fellow bookworms, today is for you! 📚

From your favourite sun-lounger spot, or perhaps tucked away in bed, there is no better way to celebrate #BookLoversDay than by kicking back with your favourite read. 

Check out our latest blog post to discover a few of our most-loved classics. Link in our bio!
  • Happy #InternationalBeerDay! 🍺

In honour of this fun global event, we’re very excited to share our most recent brew, Energi Rapsody!

What technically is a ‘Rhapsody’ you ask? It's a piece of music written without a formal structure, expressing powerful feelings and emotional excitement. In that note, our limited edition beersie is rich with highly contrasted tasting notes and colour!

This fresh brew is a Bohemian Pilsner with black pepper hops and spicy herbal undertones, that will take you on a journey.

Rhapsody comes along with a curated playlist of Rhapsodies to give you the full experience. 

Check out the playlist link in our bio!
  • July 2020 will be remembered as the month for social media going dark.

At Energi, we joined the global boycott initiative over the last 30 days in order to express our disappointment in key social media platforms allowing hate speech to fester unheeded. 

Read more about this, along with the other exciting things we and our clients have been up to during this period in our latest newsletter. Link in our bio. ✨

#GoodEnergi #BlackOut2020
  • Another year has rolled by and we are back to Matariki Festival and the new year. We recommend visiting Takutai Square at Britomart to get your hands some  delicious hangi by the @themaorikitchen and watch daily kapa haka performances

 #heartofaklcity #matariki #hangi @heartofaklcity
  • A very happy belated birthday to our amazing account directors, Melissa and Pen. ✨ 

We are so grateful for both of your diligence and hard work over the years.

You both bring so much joy to our team and clientele, we appreciate all your contributions to making the magic happen.

Special thank you to @bluebellscakery and @flowersafterhours for helping us spoil our girls. 

Let the celebrations roll on! 🥂
  • What a day! 🙌🏻 Last Friday, the Energi team ventured over to Waiheke Island for a strategic planning Away Day.

It was an action packed day filled with lots of hard work, followed by an amazing gin-making session with @thebotanicaldistillery and a divine meal at @mudbrick_nz in the evening.

2020 Here we come!👊🏼 #GoodEnergi #AwayDay2020 #WaihekeIsland
  • Our front door has undergone a bit of a makeover to include the newest addition to our family on Anzac Ave…

Very exciting times ahead!

#GoodEnergi #ArugaNZ #Headlight #Partnership
  • The cat’s officially out of the bag! 😻

We’re very excited to announce that Energi is partnering with @aruga_nz, one of Australia’s most dynamic PR agencies.

Rated the top PR agency in Australia last year, this amazing agency has a lot to offer the NZ media and communications landscape.

Backed by solid experience, Aruga has an enviable client portfolio of more than 120 big-name brands, local legends and small challenger brands in Australia and has now turned its attention to New Zealand.

Aruga NZ will be based out of our office on Anzac Ave, so drop by if you are interested in having a chat.

We are excited about what 2020 holds for us all.

#GoodEnergi #ArugaNZ #PR
  • We’ve had a fun day in the office shooting with our newest client @thefloristaklairport. Life is always brighter with flowers! 💐
  • Happy birthday for Saturday 23 May @vishalponnappa. Thank you for your diligence, integrity, creativity and strategic smarts that you bring to the Energi clients everyday. Enjoy your next 12 months traveling around the sun and your @jumpinggoatliquor birthday gift with our sincere best wishes and appreciation.

Copyright 2020 Energi Advertising Holdings Ltd

Unsightly Packaging | Energi Advertising